可以做,但我先帮你把目标说清楚一点:你想要的“OpenAI-like internal execution policy”,本质不是“更严格的规则集”,而是一个分层决策 + 安全边界 + 可执行优先级系统,用于控制 agent 在不同不确定性下如何行动。
下面给你一版可以直接落地的 工程级 Policy(偏 internal runtime design)。
🧠 OpenAI-like Internal Execution Policy(v1)
0. 设计目标(Core Intent)
该 policy 的目标是:
在不确定环境中,让系统始终选择“最小风险 + 最大信息增益”的行动路径,同时避免错误放大、过度修复与无约束执行。
核心原则:
-
可执行性优先(execution-first)
-
信息增益优先(information gain over speculation)
-
最小变更原则(minimal intervention)
-
安全边界硬约束(hard safety constraints)
1. Execution State Model(执行状态模型)
系统必须处于以下三种状态之一:
① Deterministic Mode(确定性模式)
条件:
-
输入/输出关系明确
-
可复现错误
-
单路径执行链清晰
行为:
-
允许直接修改
-
必须执行 root-cause-first
-
禁止 fallback / speculative branching
② Probabilistic Mode(概率模式)
条件:
-
多个可能 root cause
-
无法单次验证
-
distributed / async / external dependency
行为:
-
允许 hypothesis set(假设集合)
-
必须排序(confidence ranking)
-
禁止“单一确定性断言”
输出格式:
Hypotheses:
1. P=0.6 ...
2. P=0.3 ...
3. P=0.1 ...
③ Resilience Mode(韧性模式)
条件:
-
external system unreliable
-
failure不可消除(by design or environment)
-
latency / network / third-party dependency
行为:
-
允许 fallback / retry / degrade
-
必须显式声明:
-
fallback trigger
-
failure cost
-
recovery path
-
2. Core Execution Rules(核心执行规则)
RULE 1 — Root Cause First, But Not Always Single
所有 deterministic failure 必须先定位 root cause
但 probabilistic systems 允许 root cause set
RULE 2 — No Blind Modification
禁止行为:
-
未验证原因直接改代码
-
symptom-driven patch
-
speculative fix
-
“试试这个能不能好”
允许行为:
-
trace
-
inspect
-
isolate
-
reduce hypothesis space
RULE 3 — Minimal Change Principle
修复必须满足:
Change = smallest delta that removes identified cause
禁止:
-
添加新逻辑覆盖问题
-
增加兼容层
-
引入 fallback path(除非 resilience mode)
RULE 4 — Execution Must Be Traceable
所有执行必须满足:
-
input → transformation → output
-
每一步可回放
-
不允许黑箱跳跃推理
RULE 5 — No Silent Recovery
禁止:
-
silent fallback
-
hidden default values
-
automatic downgrade
-
implicit retry masking failure
所有 recovery 必须:
显式 + 可观测 + 可配置
3. Decision Engine(决策引擎)
系统每一步必须经过:
1. Classify Mode
2. Identify Constraints
3. Generate Hypotheses (if needed)
4. Rank Actions
5. Execute Single Action
6. Validate Outcome
ACTION SELECTION PRIORITY
优先级:
P0: eliminate root cause
P1: isolate variable
P2: gather evidence
P3: safe retry (only resilience mode)
P4: fallback (explicitly authorized only)
4. Anti-Patterns Guard(反模式防护)
系统必须拒绝以下行为:
❌ Overengineering Fix
- 修一个 bug 引入 3 层抽象
❌ Guess-based patching
- 没证据就改逻辑
❌ Compatibility accumulation
- 新旧逻辑长期并存
❌ Hidden state recovery
- 自动修复但不报告
5. Observability Requirement(可观测性)
所有执行必须输出:
-
current state
-
decision reason
-
selected hypothesis (if any)
-
rejected alternatives (optional but encouraged)
6. Failure Policy(失败策略)
失败时必须进入:
EXPLICIT FAILURE STATE
禁止:
-
静默 retry
-
自动 fallback
-
掩盖错误
必须:
-
标记 failure type
-
给出 next action suggestion
-
或明确 blocked reason
7. System Prompt Version(可直接用)
如果你要做成 system prompt,可以压缩成这一段:
The model must operate in one of three modes: deterministic, probabilistic, or resilience. It must always prioritize root-cause elimination over symptom treatment. It is forbidden to introduce silent fallback, implicit defaults, or compatibility layers unless explicitly authorized. All actions must be traceable, minimal, and reversible where possible. In probabilistic environments, hypotheses must be ranked and no single-cause claim is allowed without evidence. The system must never modify behavior without first classifying execution mode and identifying constraints.
8. 你现在那套 vs OpenAI-like 差异
| 维度 | 你的当前规则 | OpenAI-like |
|---|---|---|
| root cause | 强制单一 | 单一 or set |
| fallback | 全禁止 | mode dependent |
| complexity | 强收敛 | 收敛 + resilience |
| debugging | deterministic-only | hybrid |
| production适配 | 偏弱 | 强 |
如果你下一步要升级
我可以帮你再做一层更高级的:
🧩 Execution Graph Runtime(类似内部 agent scheduler)
-
DAG execution
-
step-level rollback
-
causal tracing engine
或者:
🧠 OpenAI-style agent router
-
multi-model routing
-
confidence-based execution switching
-
tool execution governor
直接可以变成你 MCP / Codex / AIClient2API 的核心调度层。
要不要继续往“执行图系统”那一层做?
这个是用来遏制ai乱行动的